Winner	Score	Runner-up	MVP
1. Cooperstown Strikers (M. Wilcox) 1994	37-9	Stone Blue Bombers (Stone)	RB Means SD
2. Stone Blue Bombers (Stone) 1995	42-27	Chicago Blitz (Simo)	QB Mitchell DET
3. St. Louis Spirits (M. Wilcox) 1996	53-30	Stone Blue Bombers (Stone)	WR M. Jackson BAL
4. Las Vegas Posse (Simo) 1997	27-22	St. Louis Spirits (M. Wilcox)	PK Hollis JAX
5. Virtual Poets (Klatt) 1998	41-41 [12-6]	Helena Handbaskets (Traczek)	QB Testaverde NYJ
6. Helena Handbaskets (Traczek) 1999	40-30	Vicodin Victors (Trewyn)	RB Levens GB
7. St. Louis Spirits (M. Wilcox) 2000	36-18	Ryan's Lions (Goff)	RB Barber NYG
8. Oakland Invaders (Simo) 2001	31-29	Barenaked Pigskins (Harvey)	PK Stover BAL
9. Los Angeles Express (Simo) 2002	34-26	Serkus Act (Goff)	RB Portis DEN
10. As You Hike It (G. Wilcox) 2003	58-44	Los Angeles Express (Simo)	QB Brady NE & WR Mason TEN
11. Ghost of Sweetness (Cline) 2004	67-60	Go For 2 (Newton)	RB R. Johnson CIN & PK Elam DEN
12. Barenaked Pigskins (Harvey) 2005	36-27	Helena Handbaskets (Traczek)	RB Bettis PIT
13. Ponz Scum (Ponczak) 2006	34-19	Eye of Newt (Newton)	PK Wilkins STL
14. Hurricane Quags (Quagliano) 2007	47-42	The Sodor Rail-Layers (Harvey)	WR R. Moss NE
15. Dublin Brawlers (Herigodt) 2008	29-22	Creighton Barrels (Traczek)	RB A. Peterson MIN